I think I'd go with the brown. Unless you're really hard, then go with the black.

i also perfer these in brown

There's something about the other ones I can't quite put my finger on, something about the straps, in some way... they are ugly.

Beautiful boots

I like these. I think you could wear them w/ more.

id prefer them in black though, just because they would go with everything i have.

these look better.

love the color

Love this. So classic and perfect.

I like these the best mainly because I feel like they are more versatile, and could easily be dressed up. The others seem more casual because of all the buckles, although I love them both in the end.

I like this style and color better

in black

The other is too much buckle for me.

This is a little more timeless than the other. I would get it in black tho. I do love black.

brown is always better than black in boots

Love the simple but sharp style of this boot

I prefer less buckles. And I love it in brown too. I want these too! :)

i like this..but maybe in black

I don't care to much for the motorcylce style.. :)

I prefer this style and think it would be elongating to the leg.

I really like the brown because they remind me of riding boots where as the black ones remind me of S&M.

Love these. Great for everything, and for many years to come.

I love brown boots for fall

I kinda don't like all the buckles on the motorcycle boots

brown is the new black.

This one is more sleek and would work with more outfits.

i'm digging the brown riding boots. the black moto boots would look better without the 2 straps in the middle...imo :)