love it! gotta have it!

I love this stuff! It really is like having false eyelashes!

Black

it sucks you had a bad experience. I buy the badgal blue and it's worked like a charm for me.

Finally got this. It's really nice for creating thick lashes but always leaves a smudge under my lower lash line that I have to wipe away at least once throughout the day. Too bad. I won't be purchasing this again.

Actually, I've had just about the same success with my chanel. But I do really love it.

lasts REALLY long and doesn't clump

without doubt

@triplyksis: isn't that the truth ;) this is perfect for "girls night out"@Adriannaa: I use this often and love it!! it doesn't quite have the staying power of some other mascaras but it sure does give you volume! it's a bit dramatic, so I normally only use it for evening wear anyway. @katystardust: have you tried Sephora's eye makeup remover? I tried Big Tease as part of a holiday kit, but wasn't able to wield the bizarre brush - I guess I need to give it another try!

I've tried this - and it definitely works, but I HATE removing it. I feel like I'm pulling out my eyelashes. I absolutely positively love Bare Esscentuals Big Tease Mascara. It's my all time favorite, the brush is the best...helps you volumize and get all the stragglers with one flick of your wrist.

I love this one. My absolute favorite mascara!!!

I haven't tried any of these, but of the three this is the one I have heard the most ranting and raving about. I am seriously thinking of buying it myself. If you do buy it, let me know how it turns out please.

heard this one was thee bomb! Tried it at Macys...i like it

I haven't tried any from this list, but everyone wants to be a bad girl once in a while.

Benefit is good stuff!

everything by Benefit is incredible!

I haven't tried either of these, but I've heard that this one's really good.

i'm obsessed with the badgal lash ( i used to work for benefit)

the ultimate volumizing mascara ;)

I swear by this in the face of all other mascaras.

Big, bold lashes fast!