smudges! My favorite cream liner is by a no-name company called Mad Minerals. For $8, their eyeliner will survive a nuclear fall-out.

Everyone needs a good eyeliner.

I have to try this!

I've been using this for a few years now - it's great and versatile. Depending on the brush you use, you can create a soft smokey look with a straight line brush, a natural, barely there line with a traditional eyeliner brush, or go for dramatic cat eyes using a slanted eye brush and topped with a matte powder (or a glimmer shadow for extra glam). Easy to use, easy to remove. Smashbox cream liner is a must. TIPS: Using BRUSH #9 pick up a small amount of product and apply to the upper and/or lower lashline, following the natural contour of the eye. Try using an eye liner that contrasts your eye color to make them stand out (e.g. Blue eyes try a deep brown like MIDNIGHT BROWN or a green like MIDNIGHT GREEN. Green eyes try a rich purple like MIDNIGHT PURPLE and brown eyes can try a brighter gold like SMASHING IMAGE.) remember, rich black like SMASHING CAVIAR gives great definition and looks striking on all eye colors.

Andreah said it. I'm in love with these liners. So smooth!

I began using this for a few years now - it's great and versatile. Depending on the brush you use, you can create a soft smokey look with a staight line brush, a natural, barely there line with am eyeliner brush, or go for dramatic cat eyes using a slanted eye brush and topped with a matte powder (or a glimmer for extra glam). Easy to use, easy to remove. Smashbox cream liner is a winner.

these liners are what made smashbox famous they are just wonderful!!!!!!!!!!!!

I was reading about cream eyeliner in Allure??? I think I want to try it but don't know if I'm brave enough. I'm afraid I'll mess it up. I'd love to here what someone other then a makeup artist thinks of it and how to use it.

This is my first cream eyeliner/eyeshadow. Still playing with this one... so far so good! Caviar/Lava Cream Eyeliner Duo

Smudge proof...I guess thats why you can never seem to get your eyeliner off your contacts

Better then MAC, it's completely smudge proof.

I just got a pot of caviar and midnight brown - I'm so excited to use it!

I have this and still have to put Benefit's SheLaq over it because it does end up smudging after a few hours, but then again, I have oily lids.