This is great as a top-coat

dramatic lashes

I just bought Iconic (which isn't waterproof, just smudgeproof, btw) and it is freaking fabulous! It makes your eyelashes stand up and just, damn, you know? Iconic can also be used as a base/primer for mascara. I would buy Iconic right away and ask one of the makeup specialists to put some Iconic on you and layer some Black Out over it and wear it home and see how it does. You can always buy the Black Out later, but I'd bet it's going to smudge on you without a primer to set it in place.

If they still carry it...and I'm praying they do b/c I need a new one pretty soon.

You've suggested Iconic before, so I guess I really do need to check it out! :)

This smudged on me too, so I feel your pain. The waterproof one was a little better and the limited edition DiorShow (called Iconic) is my favorite and doesn't smudge at all.

I'd be interested to know what you think of this? Everything smudges on me, even the expensive stuff.