hottest!!

I'd like to see a third choice. But if I have to choose between these 2, then this would be the one....Less is always more! Congrats!

Simplicity is the key

hands down.. no contest

Though the other one is classic but this one is glamous. Gorg!

Love them both, but this is the one I would pick.

Simple but timeless

Simple and timeless.

i luv dis 1

I like the setting on this one

definitely the pear

this one is simple, elegant, and classic. just be sure they aren't blood diamonds!

so elgent

Tiffany's is always the right choice!

nice but simple

simple

TAKES MY BREATH AWAY!!!

Totally awesome ring. I love this one.

simple...yet not too 'out there' :)

very nice !!!

the other ring is much like my own engagement ring, but i like this one better LOL!

tiffany's has a huge mark-up. why throw away money just because of the box... not crazy about either...

always go for tiffany !! oh my osh youve got to send me the wedding photos darling !

simply beautiful

this is grand

i like them both but since i only have one engagement ring finger go for simple and elegant

you don't need all that funky stuff. tiffany rings are stunning and perfect and they sparkle like nothing else!

simple but look strong!

this one is pretty as a pin. the others too flashy, i guess it depends on the girls personality

this one is cleaner and prettier. The other one has too much stuff

beautiful

much more classic looking...more elegant

Looks magical

Love this one! It's got cleaner design.

pretty and easier to clean

This looks more romantic to me.

love

This blings more and just looks more timeless

hard to choose, but I'll take this one because it looks vintage

I like the detail on the band, this choice looks more like a one-of-a-kind, where the Tiffany is beautiful, but looks unoriginal.

This is absolutely breath taking!

This one is different, I like it

this one. so traditional

it's different

the detail is pretty

Love the side detailing

Beautiful!

Yeah Baby! This is the Ultimate Princenss Ring. This would have to be the one!

Tiffany is always great but in this case the more the better!!! Really like the side detail on this one. Good luck!!

This one is stunning. Very similar to the one my mom and my dad designed it for her! I think the round diamond versus the oval one is better.

love the detail

WOW!!!

hands down, ring finger up!

its beautiful!

I LOVE TIFFANY BUT HOW UNIQUE IS THIS

The details in this ring are AMAZING. Also not many women are fans of the pear-cut. Oh - and I own a jewelry store, so I know. ;)

the additional detail will be appreciated!

Unique, stylish and beautiful. The other one is just too common.

SOOOOOOOOOOO CUTE!!! FOR ME???

this ring is beautiful

assuming the diamonds are good quality....both are beautiful rings

although tiffany is, well, TIFFANY, i love the subtle band details on this one

Ooh, it's a little similar to my engagement ring!

The detail is beautiful. Definitely a ring I would like to brag about.

simply beautiful!

It would be even nicer if it was princess cut

this one is too busy but i love the design!

for sure...gorgeous ring!!!

Wow, that is really beautiful. If you like this a lot, consider looking at some Verragio.

details are pretty

Hard Pick!!! I definately like them both but this one is more on my line of being intriquite.

Wow..two good choices but this one's intricacy will make her feel special and unique!!

more bling

Both are beautiful. I how this one will sparkles down the side of this ring, but if your girl prefers simple, sleek lines, I'd go with the Tiffany.

Very unusual!

both are beautiful, though.